Home Resources Circular Clarification regarding the scope of “as is / as is, where is...

Clarification regarding the scope of “as is / as is, where is basis” mentioned in the GST Circulars issued on the basis of recommendation of the GST Council in its meetings

0
279

Circular No.: 236/30/2024-GST
Date of Circular: 11th October 2024
Relevant Sections and Rules:

  • CGST Act, 2017:
    • Section 168(1): Power to issue instructions
  • Relevant Concept:
    • Regularization of tax position on “as is” or “as is, where is basis”

Clarification on Scope of “As is” or “As is, Where is Basis” in GST Circulars

  1. Background – Reason for Issuance:
    Taxpayers and field officers had expressed confusion over the meaning and scope of the phrase “as is” or “as is, where is basis” in past GST circulars issued following Council recommendations to regularize tax discrepancies.
    ➤ This circular clarifies the legal intent behind those phrases, particularly for retrospective regularization of GST rates or classification issues.
  2. When Regularization is Applicable:
    Regularization on “as is” or “as is, where is basis” applies to past periods where:
  • Genuine interpretational issues existed due to competing GST rate entries, or
  • Suppliers followed divergent practices (some paying nil or lower rates, others paying higher rates).

➤ In such cases, GST paid at the lower rate is accepted as full discharge of liability.
➤ However, no refund is permitted if tax was paid at a higher rate.

  1. Meaning of “As is, Where is Basis” in GST Context:
  • Borrowed from real estate law where property is sold as-is.
  • In GST, it means:
    • The tax paid as per taxpayer’s bona fide interpretation (even nil) is accepted,
    • No recovery of tax differential, and
    • No refund if a higher rate was paid.
  1. Treatment of Tax Declared at Lower or Nil Rate:
  • If taxpayer filed GST returns declaring nil or lower rate due to reasonable interpretation and the Council later regularized it,
    ➤ Such payment is considered full compliance.
  • Those who paid a higher rate are not entitled to refund.

Illustrations Provided:

Illustration 1:

  • Competing rates: 5% vs 12%
  • Taxpayers paid either rate
  • Council reduces rate to 5% and regularizes past
    ➤ 5% payers – no further tax payable; 12% payers – no refund.

Illustration 2:

  • Some paid 5%, others claimed nil due to mistaken exemption belief
  • Council affirms 5% rate and regularizes past
    ➤ Nil and 5% payers – both considered compliant; No additional tax or refund.

Illustration 3:

  • Mix of 5%, 12%, and non-payment
  • Council affirms 12% rate and regularizes past
    ➤ 5% and 12% payers – no further tax or refund;
    ➤ Non-payers – must pay 12% now (regularization not applicable).
  1. Instruction to Field Officers:
    Tax positions reflected in returns filed and covered under regularization must be accepted as full tax discharge, unless no tax was paid at all.

Source: Circular No.: 236/30/2024-GST

LEAVE A REPLY