Home Case Laws Collection of any amount under threat and coercion before assessing tax liability...

Collection of any amount under threat and coercion before assessing tax liability is not valid.

0
370

Remark Flour Mills (P.) Ltd. v. State of Gujarat

High Court of Gujarat

Special Civil Application No. 4835 of 2018

Category: Provisional Attachment, Coercive Recovery, Jurisdiction of Show Cause Notice

Date of Judgment: 19 April 2018

Relevant Sections: Sections 74(1), 74(3), 83 of the CGST Act

 

Facts of the Case

[Para 2–6]

  1. Petitioner is engaged in supplying wheat, meslin, and cereal flour. They claimed that products packed in over 25 kg were branded, and others were unbranded and exempt.
  2. Department conducted a search on 20.02.2018 and allegedly coerced the petitioners into handing over post-dated cheques worth ₹19,74,886.
  3. A show cause notice dated 27.02.2018 was issued for recovery of ₹36,88,706 towards unpaid CGST and SGST for July 2017–Feb 2018.
  4. On the same day, provisional attachment orders on petitioners’ bank accounts were issued.
  5. A second show cause notice dated 19.03.2018 was later issued under Section 74(3) proposing recovery of ₹1,29,13,928 for the same period.

 

Question(s) in Consideration

[Para 7, 9, 13]

  1. Whether the collection of post-dated cheques under alleged coercion during investigation was lawful.
  2. Whether the department had jurisdiction to issue a second show cause notice under Section 74(3) for the same period already covered under Section 74(1).
  3. Whether the provisional attachment of bank accounts was justified in law without establishing necessity.

 

Observation of Court

[Para 7–12, 14–16]

  1. On cheques: Collection of post-dated cheques under coercion is impermissible unless voluntarily issued to avoid attachment. There was no basis to suggest voluntary issue in this case.
  2. On second SCN under Section 74(3): Section 74(3) allows further demands only for periods other than those covered under Section 74(1). Issuing a second notice for the same period enlarging the demand violates statutory provisions.
  3. On provisional attachment: Section 83 permits attachment during pending proceedings only if necessary to protect revenue. The department failed to demonstrate urgency or necessity, rendering the action unjustified.

 

Judgment of the Court

[Para 17]

  1. Directed the department to return the three cheques collected on 20.02.2018.
  2. Quashed the second show cause notice dated 19.03.2018, while allowing the department to raise further demand through lawful means, if permissible.
  3. Set aside the provisional attachment of bank accounts, subject to:
    • Petitioner maintaining ₹50 lakhs worth of stock until adjudication.
    • Filing an undertaking to this effect by 25.04.2018.
  4. Petitioners’ rights to defend themselves against the original notice dated 27.02.2018 remain intact.

 

Between Fine Lines

  • Coercive recovery through post-dated cheques without ascertained liability is illegal.
  • Department cannot revise or enhance liability for the same period using Section 74(3) after invoking Section 74(1).
  • Provisional attachment requires demonstrable urgency; it is not automatic.
  • Courts will scrutinize the necessity and proportionality of coercive and protective measures.
  • Due process and proper jurisdictional exercise are essential in GST proceedings.

Summary of Referred Cases

Name Citation Summary Verdict
Atul Motors (P.) Ltd. v. State of Gujarat SCA No. 959 of 2015 Held that collection of cheques during raids under coercion is impermissible. Departmental action set aside
Automark Industries (I) Ltd. v. State of Gujarat 2014 SCC Online Guj 14217 Discussed conditions under which provisional attachment is justified under VAT Act. Provisional attachment held improper

 

Takeaway

“No Tax Before Test: Limits on Coercive Recovery and Scope of Show Cause Notices under GST”

LEAVE A REPLY