Remark Flour Mills (P.) Ltd. v. State of Gujarat
High Court of Gujarat
Special Civil Application No. 4835 of 2018
Category: Provisional Attachment, Coercive Recovery, Jurisdiction of Show Cause Notice
Date of Judgment: 19 April 2018
Relevant Sections: Sections 74(1), 74(3), 83 of the CGST Act
Facts of the Case
[Para 2–6]
- Petitioner is engaged in supplying wheat, meslin, and cereal flour. They claimed that products packed in over 25 kg were branded, and others were unbranded and exempt.
- Department conducted a search on 20.02.2018 and allegedly coerced the petitioners into handing over post-dated cheques worth ₹19,74,886.
- A show cause notice dated 27.02.2018 was issued for recovery of ₹36,88,706 towards unpaid CGST and SGST for July 2017–Feb 2018.
- On the same day, provisional attachment orders on petitioners’ bank accounts were issued.
- A second show cause notice dated 19.03.2018 was later issued under Section 74(3) proposing recovery of ₹1,29,13,928 for the same period.
Question(s) in Consideration
[Para 7, 9, 13]
- Whether the collection of post-dated cheques under alleged coercion during investigation was lawful.
- Whether the department had jurisdiction to issue a second show cause notice under Section 74(3) for the same period already covered under Section 74(1).
- Whether the provisional attachment of bank accounts was justified in law without establishing necessity.
Observation of Court
[Para 7–12, 14–16]
- On cheques: Collection of post-dated cheques under coercion is impermissible unless voluntarily issued to avoid attachment. There was no basis to suggest voluntary issue in this case.
- On second SCN under Section 74(3): Section 74(3) allows further demands only for periods other than those covered under Section 74(1). Issuing a second notice for the same period enlarging the demand violates statutory provisions.
- On provisional attachment: Section 83 permits attachment during pending proceedings only if necessary to protect revenue. The department failed to demonstrate urgency or necessity, rendering the action unjustified.
Judgment of the Court
[Para 17]
- Directed the department to return the three cheques collected on 20.02.2018.
- Quashed the second show cause notice dated 19.03.2018, while allowing the department to raise further demand through lawful means, if permissible.
- Set aside the provisional attachment of bank accounts, subject to:
- Petitioner maintaining ₹50 lakhs worth of stock until adjudication.
- Filing an undertaking to this effect by 25.04.2018.
- Petitioners’ rights to defend themselves against the original notice dated 27.02.2018 remain intact.
Between Fine Lines
- Coercive recovery through post-dated cheques without ascertained liability is illegal.
- Department cannot revise or enhance liability for the same period using Section 74(3) after invoking Section 74(1).
- Provisional attachment requires demonstrable urgency; it is not automatic.
- Courts will scrutinize the necessity and proportionality of coercive and protective measures.
- Due process and proper jurisdictional exercise are essential in GST proceedings.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Name | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| Atul Motors (P.) Ltd. v. State of Gujarat | SCA No. 959 of 2015 | Held that collection of cheques during raids under coercion is impermissible. | Departmental action set aside |
| Automark Industries (I) Ltd. v. State of Gujarat | 2014 SCC Online Guj 14217 | Discussed conditions under which provisional attachment is justified under VAT Act. | Provisional attachment held improper |
Takeaway
“No Tax Before Test: Limits on Coercive Recovery and Scope of Show Cause Notices under GST”




