Case Title: Shri Tyres v. State Tax Officer
Court: High Court of Madras
Petition Number: W.P. No. 19756 of 2021, W.M.P. No. 21034 of 2021
Category of Dispute: Procedure under Section 73 – Show Cause Notice / Order – Rule 142 Violation
Date of Judgement: 21 September 2021
Relevant Section: Section 73 of the CGST Act, 2017; Rule 142 of CGST Rules, 2017
Facts of the Case [¶3–4, ¶7–8]
- The petitioner challenged an assessment order dated 25.08.2021 issued under Section 73 of the CGST Act, 2017.
- The petitioner raised two grounds:
- No personal hearing was granted [¶4(a)].
- The order was not preceded by mandatory forms GST DRC-01 and GST DRC-01A, violating Rule 142 of the CGST Rules, 2017 [¶4(b)].
- The State admitted that a personal hearing had indeed been granted on 09.07.2021 [¶7], but accepted that the impugned order was not preceded by Forms GST DRC-01 and DRC-01A [¶8].
Questions in Consideration [¶4, ¶9–10]
- Whether the issuance of Forms GST DRC-01 and DRC-01A prior to passing the assessment order under Section 73 is mandatory?
- Whether the absence of these forms invalidates the assessment order?
Observations of the Court [¶10–12]
- Rule 142(1) and 142(1A) of the CGST Rules mandate the issuance of Form GST DRC-01 (summary of SCN) and Form GST DRC-01A (pre-SCN intimation) respectively [¶10].
- These requirements are not merely procedural; their omission causes actual prejudice to the assessee as they serve as a basis for the taxpayer to respond or settle the demand before formal adjudication [¶12].
- In this case, the non-issuance of these forms rendered the proceedings non-compliant with statutory procedure, warranting interference [¶12].
Judgement of the Court [¶13–14]
- The impugned order dated 25.08.2021 was set aside solely on the ground of non-compliance with Rule 142 of the CGST Rules, 2017 [¶13(a)].
- No view was expressed on the merits of the tax liability [¶13(b)].
- The department was directed to initiate fresh proceedings de novo, strictly adhering to Rule 142 and complete them within 12 weeks from the order date (i.e., by 14.12.2021) [¶13(c)–(d)].
- Writ petition and miscellaneous petition were accordingly disposed [¶14].
Between Fine Lines
- The Court emphasized that procedural compliance with Rule 142 is not a mere formality—it safeguards taxpayer rights.
- Forms GST DRC-01 and DRC-01A are mandatory prerequisites to a valid assessment under Section 73.
- Even if a hearing is given, failure to issue statutory forms renders the order vulnerable.
- The judgement mandates de novo proceedings if procedural lapses are proven.
- Tax officers must scrupulously adhere to the notice and pre-notice intimation requirements to avoid judicial invalidation.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Name of Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| None cited explicitly | — | No other case laws were cited or relied upon in the judgment. | Not applicable |
Takeaway
“No DRC, No Demand – Procedural Safeguards are Not Optional”




