Home Resources Circular GST applicability on liquidated damages, compensation and penalty arising out of breach...

GST applicability on liquidated damages, compensation and penalty arising out of breach of contract or other provisions of law

0
481

Circular No.: 178/10/2022-GST
Date of Circular: 3rd August 2022
Relevant Sections and Rules:

  • CGST Act, 2017:
    • Section 7: Definition of supply
    • Section 9: Levy of GST
    • Schedule II, Para 5(e): Declared service—“agreeing to the obligation to refrain from an act or to tolerate an act or a situation, or to do an act”
    • Section 168(1): Power to issue instructions
  • Contract Act, 1872: Sections 73 and 74 – Liquidated damages and compensation for breach

Summary of Clarifications Provided (One Paragraph per Clarification):

  1. Scope of Para 5(e) of Schedule II—Declared Service:
    The expression “agreeing to the obligation to refrain from an act or to tolerate an act or a situation, or to do an act” covers only cases where such obligations arise from a contractual agreement—either express or implied—and consideration flows in return. Mere flow of money due to events like damages or penalties does not constitute supply unless such agreement and consideration exist.
  2. Liquidated Damages:
    Payments made as compensation for breach of contract—like delayed construction penalties or forfeiture of earnest money—are not a supply under GST, as they do not involve a contract to tolerate an act. Such payments are not consideration for any service and are therefore not taxable.
  3. Compensation for Cancellation of Coal Blocks (2014 Case):
    The compensation paid to previous allottees for coal block cancellations was made under statutory obligation, not a contractual agreement. Therefore, this is not a service of tolerating cancellation and is not taxable under GST.
  4. Cheque Dishonour Penalty:
    Penalties imposed for dishonoured cheques are not for tolerating an act but rather to discourage it. Since there is no agreement to tolerate cheque bounce, such penalties are not taxable.
  5. Penalties for Violation of Law:
    Fines for pollution, mining excess, traffic violations, etc., are not consideration for any service. They are penal in nature and do not involve any agreement to tolerate a breach. Hence, not taxable.
  6. Forfeiture of Salary/Bond by Employer:
    Amounts recovered from employees for leaving early (salary forfeiture or bond) are to deter premature exit, not to tolerate it. Since no service is provided in return, no GST applies.
  7. Compensation for Non-Collection of Toll (Demonetization):
    Compensation paid by NHAI for suspension of toll during demonetization was in lieu of providing road access services. Since the service continued but was paid by a third party (NHAI), such compensation is not taxable afresh.
  8. Late Payment Surcharge or Fee:
    Surcharges or penalties for late payment are ancillary to the main supply and are naturally bundled. Hence, they are taxed at the same rate as the principal supply.
  9. Fixed Capacity Charges for Electricity:
    Fixed charges for power are part of the price for electricity, which is exempt from GST. They do not amount to a payment for tolerating under-consumption and hence are not taxable.
  10. Cancellation Charges:
    Charges for cancellation of travel, hotel bookings, tours, etc., are considered part of the original bundled supply. They are taxable at the same rate as the principal supply (e.g., air travel, railways). However, forfeiture of earnest money in property sale/bid failure is not taxable, as it is a deterrent, not a service.

Source: Circular No.: 178/10/2022-GST

LEAVE A REPLY