Home Case Laws GST demand against tobacco distributor set aside as non-service of show cause...

GST demand against tobacco distributor set aside as non-service of show cause notice and denial of hearing were held to violate principles of natural justice

0
171

Case: Deepak Sales Corporation & Anr. v. Additional Commissioner GST Delhi North & Anr.

Court: Delhi High Court
Petition No.: W.P.(C) 5103/2025 & CM APPL. 23346/2025
Judgment Date: 15 July 2025
Category of Dispute: Input Tax Credit (ITC) – Fraudulent availment & Natural Justice
Relevant Sections: Section 74(1), Section 50, Section 122(1), Section 122(3) of the CGST Act, 2017; corresponding provisions of IGST Act, Haryana SGST Act, Section 11 of GST (Compensation to States) Act.

Facts (Paras 2–7)

The petitioners, Deepak Sales Corporation (a proprietary concern of Mr. Deepak Dhall), are engaged in wholesale distribution of tobacco products. The firm supplied goods to registered buyers such as M/s Om Traders, M/s Joles Trado Pvt Ltd, and M/s A.R. Traders, duly raising invoices and paying GST/IGST liability.

The GST Department conducted investigations against several exporters and firms suspected of GST fraud. During this, the petitioners’ buyers were found to be non-existent, and it was alleged that on the basis of invoices raised by the petitioners, these buyers availed wrongful ITC, including cess. Consequently, an Order-in-Original dated 4 February 2025 was passed confirming a tax demand of ₹3.05 crore IGST and ₹10.46 crore cess, along with penalty and interest, under Section 74 of the CGST Act.

The petitioners argued that no Show Cause Notice (SCN) was ever served on them, and no opportunity of personal hearing was granted.


Questions before the Court

  • Whether the non-service of SCN and absence of personal hearing invalidated the order-in-original?

  • Whether the demand raised against the petitioners could be sustained without compliance with principles of natural justice?


Observations (Paras 9–13)

The Court noted that the GST Department itself could not confirm whether the SCN or personal hearing notice was served. The petitioners produced GST portal records showing no SCN was uploaded against their account. The Court held that non-service of SCN and non-affording of hearing constitutes a clear breach of natural justice. Without these, the demand order could not stand.


Judgment (Paras 13–17)

The Court set aside the impugned order-in-original only insofar as it related to the petitioners. Directions were issued:

  • Petitioners to be given 30 days to file a reply to the SCN.

  • Proper access to GST portal must be ensured.

  • Fresh adjudication after providing a personal hearing and considering the petitioners’ reply.

Thus, the writ petition was disposed of with liberty to the department to re-adjudicate after following due process.


Table of Earlier Cases Referred

(This judgment does not cite earlier case law; references are limited to statutory provisions. Hence, no comparative case law table is applicable here.)


Between Fine Lines

This case reiterates that no GST demand can survive without proper service of show cause notice and opportunity of hearing. For businesses, it highlights the importance of tracking GST portal updates and preserving records of notice service. For the department, it emphasizes strict adherence to natural justice to prevent orders from being struck down.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY