Home Case Laws No reversal of Input Tax Credit of loss by consumption of Input...

No reversal of Input Tax Credit of loss by consumption of Input which is inherent to manufacturing loss.

0
403

Case Title: ARS Steels & Alloy International (P.) Ltd. v. State Tax Officer, Group-I, Chennai

Court: High Court of Madras

Petition Number: W.P. Nos. 2885, 2888, 2890, 3930, 3933 and 3936 of 2020

Category of Dispute: Input Tax Credit

Date of Judgement: June 24, 2021

Relevant Section: Section 17(5)(h) of the CGST Act, 2017

 

Facts of the Case

  1. The petitioner is engaged in manufacturing MS Billets and Ingots using MS scrap as input and subsequently manufacturing TMT/CTD Bars from billets. During the manufacturing process, a small quantity of input is inherently lost…(Para 6).
  2. The department passed assessment orders reversing proportionate Input Tax Credit (ITC) based on loss of input during manufacturing, relying on Section 17(5)(h) of the CGST Act, which disallows ITC on goods lost, stolen, destroyed, etc. Para 6).
  3. In one of the writ petitions (W.P. No. 3936/2020), an additional issue of stock reconciliation was raised, where documents such as vehicle gate passes were not submitted at the assessment stage. The Court permitted appeal on this factual matter before the appellate authority. (Para2 and 3)

Question(s) in Consideration

  1. Whether ITC can be disallowed under Section 17(5)(h) of the CGST Act for input lost during the manufacturing process as a natural and inherent consequence of production? (Para 5)

 

Observation of the Court

  1. The court held that losses inherent to the manufacturing process, such as evaporation or minimal input loss, do not equate to loss by theft, destruction, or disposal as contemplated in Section 17(5)(h) …(Para 10-11).
  2. It relied on Rupa & Co. Ltd. v. CESTAT, 2015 (324) ELT 295, where a Division Bench held that Cenvat credit is allowed on the total input used, even if not all of it appears in the finished product due to natural losses…(Para 14).
  3. The term “inputs contained in finished product” must be interpreted in the context of manufacturing realities and not rigid semantics. (para 14)

 

Judgement of the Court

  1. The High Court held that applying Section 17(5)(h) to deny ITC for inherent manufacturing loss is legally misconceived…(Para 15).
  2. Impugned orders were quashed to the extent of such ITC reversal.
  3. W.P. Nos. 2885, 3930, and 3933 were allowed in full; W.P. Nos. 2888, 2890, and 3936 were partly allowed (Para 16).

 

Between Fine Lines

  • The court clarified that natural and inevitable input loss during manufacturing is not “loss” under Section 17(5)(h).
  • ITC cannot be denied for such consumption losses.
  • Interpretation must consider industrial realities, not literal wording alone.
  • Relief granted by setting aside wrongful reversal of ITC.
  • Revenue’s reading of blocked credit provision was found overextended.

 

Summary of Referred Cases

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
Rupa & Co. Ltd. v. CESTAT 2015 (324) ELT 295 (Mad) Loss of input due to manufacturing process is inevitable; ITC allowed on full input consumed Credit allowable despite partial output loss

 

Download Judgement

LEAVE A REPLY