Home Case Laws Order Passed Without Personal Hearing Set Aside by Calcutta High Court

Order Passed Without Personal Hearing Set Aside by Calcutta High Court

0
289

Case Name: Howrah Chemical & Solvent vs. Joint Commissioner, Commercial Taxes, Shibpur Charge & Ors.
Court Name: Calcutta High Court
Petition Number: WPA 10784 of 2025
Category of Dispute: Principles of Natural Justice – Opportunity of Personal Hearing
Date of Judgment: 21 May 2025
Relevant Sections:

  • Section 73 of CGST/WBGST Act, 2017 – Determination of tax

  • Section 75(5) of CGST/WBGST Act, 2017 – Opportunity of personal hearing
    Citation: Not cited from any publisher


🧾 Facts of the Case:

[Para 1-2]
The petitioner challenged the order dated 20.01.2025 under Section 73 of the CGST/WBGST Act for the period April 2020–March 2021. A show cause notice (SCN) was issued on 22.10.2024. The petitioner sought a 20-day adjournment on 21.11.2024 and requested a personal hearing, but the order was passed ex parte without accommodating the request.


❓Questions in Consideration:

[Para 3]
Whether the order dated 20.01.2025 passed under Section 73 of the CGST/WBGST Act without granting a personal hearing and without considering the adjournment request violates Section 75(5) and the principles of natural justice?


👨‍⚖️ Observations of the Court:

[Para 3-4]

  • The order was passed without following the mandatory provisions of Section 75(5) of the Act, which requires that a personal hearing must be granted where an adverse decision is contemplated.

  • The petitioner’s request for adjournment and hearing was ignored without justification, thus violating natural justice.

  • The court held the order to be illegal and not sustainable.


⚖️ Judgement of the Court:

[Para 4-8]

  • The impugned order dated 20.01.2025 is set aside.

  • The matter is remanded for fresh adjudication after granting an opportunity of personal hearing.

  • The petitioner may file a response to the SCN within 10 days (mandatory timeline).

  • All consequential actions, including recovery, are quashed.

  • Any recovered amount must be reversed and re-credited to the petitioner’s credit ledger.

  • The proper officer must conclude proceedings within 4 weeks of receiving the response or the order, whichever is later.

  • The writ petition is disposed accordingly.


🧵 Between Fine Lines:

  1. An order under Section 73 cannot be passed without giving a proper opportunity of hearing.

  2. Ignoring a request for adjournment violates Section 75(5) and principles of natural justice.

  3. Such orders are liable to be quashed and remanded back for re-adjudication.

  4. Recovery actions taken based on the illegal order must also be reversed.

  5. Courts ensure that taxpayers’ rights are protected during adjudication processes.


📚 Summary of Referred Cases

(No referred cases were cited by either party in this judgment.)

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY