Case: Principal Commissioner of Income Tax 5 Kolkata v. Syama Prasad Mookherjee Port Kolkata
Court: Calcutta High Court, Division Bench
Coram: Justice Rajarshi Bharadwaj and Justice Uday Kumar
Case No.: ITA 49 of 2026 with GA 2 of 2026
Date of Judgment: 21 August 2026
Assessment Year: 2018-19
Outcome: Revenue’s Appeal Dismissed / Decided in favour of the assessee.
Calcutta High Court Rules on Superannuation, Gratuity and PF/ESI Contributions
The Calcutta High Court has upheld the ITAT’s deletion of substantial disallowances relating to contributions made by Syama Prasad Mookherjee Port Kolkata towards its Superannuation Fund and approved Gratuity Fund, as well as the disallowance concerning employees’ PF/ESI contributions.
The Court held that contributions made specifically to bridge an actuarial deficit cannot be treated as ordinary annual contributions merely because the deficit was addressed over several years. It further held that where the regulations specifically applicable to the assessee prescribe no due date for depositing employees’ contributions, an artificial deadline generated through tax-return software cannot trigger disallowance under Section 36(1)(va).
Background
For AY 2018-19, the Assessing Officer completed assessment under Section 143(3) read with Section 144B and determined total income at ₹876,16,93,450. Among the additions and disallowances were:
- ₹710,68,55,297 relating to contributions towards the Superannuation Fund;
- ₹33,11,01,366 relating to contributions towards the approved Gratuity Fund; and
- ₹8,38,35,219 relating to employees’ PF/ESI contributions under Section 36(1)(va).
The CIT(A), National Faceless Appeal Centre, deleted the additions. The ITAT, Kolkata Bench “B”, affirmed the CIT(A)’s decision. The Revenue thereafter approached the Calcutta High Court under Section 260A.
Superannuation Fund: Rule 87 Ceiling Not Applicable to Actuarial Deficit Funding
The Assessing Officer had applied the 27% ceiling under Rule 87 to the contribution towards the Superannuation Fund and disallowed ₹710.68 crore.
The High Court held that the legal character of a contribution depends upon its purpose. The contribution in question was an ad hoc interim contribution intended to bridge the gap between the fund’s assets and its actuarial liabilities. Such a contribution was neither an ordinary annual contribution under Rule 87 nor an initial contribution under Rule 88.
The Court rejected the Revenue’s argument that repeated funding of shortfalls over several years converted such payments into ordinary annual contributions. A persistent deficit caused by earlier funding constraints did not alter the character of payments made to remedy an actuarial deficit.
Accordingly, the deletion of the ₹710,68,55,297 disallowance was upheld.
Gratuity Fund: 8.33% Ceiling Cannot Restrict Actuarial Shortfall Contribution
The Court also upheld deletion of the ₹33,11,01,366 disallowance concerning the approved Gratuity Fund.
It held that a distinction must be maintained between an ordinary annual contribution and a contribution specifically made to bridge the gap between the fund’s actuarial liability and its actual availability.
The Court observed that Section 36(1)(v) itself does not impose the 8.33% ceiling relied upon by the Revenue. It further held that once the Gratuity Fund had been approved by the Commissioner, the Assessing Officer could not sit in judgment over that approval or disregard the approved status of the fund in assessment proceedings.
The Court accordingly held that the Rule 103 ceiling did not apply to the specific actuarial deficit-funding contribution involved in the case.
PF/ESI: No Statutory Due Date, No Disallowance Under Section 36(1)(va)
Another important issue concerned the disallowance of ₹8,38,35,219 towards employees’ PF/ESI contributions.
The assessee was governed by the Kolkata Port Trust (Non-contributory Provident Fund) Regulations, 1988, which did not prescribe a due date for depositing the employees’ share.
The High Court held that the general deadline of the 15th of the following month under the Employees’ Provident Fund Scheme could not be applied to the respondent. The date appearing in Form 3CD had been entered because the e-filing software compulsorily required a date.
The Court held that without a legally prescribed due date, there could be no “delay” capable of triggering disallowance under Section 36(1)(va). The deletion of the disallowance was therefore upheld.
Decision
The High Court found no perversity or arbitrariness in the ITAT’s order. Substantial questions of law Nos. 1, 2, 3 and 5 were answered in the negative and Question No. 4 in the affirmative, all against the Revenue and in favour of the assessee.
The Revenue’s appeal against the ITAT order dated 18 November 2024 for AY 2018-19 was held to be devoid of merit. No order as to costs was made.
Key Takeaway
Contributions made to bridge an actuarial deficit in approved Superannuation or Gratuity Funds do not become ordinary annual contributions merely because the deficit is funded over several years. Further, where the applicable provident fund regulations prescribe no statutory due date, an artificial software-generated deadline cannot form the basis of a disallowance under Section 36(1)(va).




