Home Resources Circular Reduction of Government Litigation – fixing monetary limits for filing appeals or...

Reduction of Government Litigation – fixing monetary limits for filing appeals or applications by the Department before GSTAT, High Courts and Supreme Court

0
343

Circular No.: 207/01/2024-GST
Date of Circular: 26th June 2024
Relevant Sections and Rules:

  • Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017:
    • Section 120: Power to fix monetary limits for filing appeals
    • Section 168(1): Power to issue instructions

Summary of Clarification Provided:

  1. Fixing Monetary Thresholds for Filing Appeals by the Department:
    To reduce government litigation in GST, the CBIC—under powers granted by Section 120—has fixed monetary limits below which no appeal or SLP shall be filed by central tax authorities:
Appellate Forum Monetary Limit (Tax Disputed)
GST Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) ₹20,00,000
High Court ₹1,00,00,000
Supreme Court ₹2,00,00,000

These limits apply to all GST cases (including CGST, SGST/UTGST, IGST, and Compensation Cess), subject to exclusions detailed below.

  1. Guidelines for Applying the Limits:
  • Tax-only disputes: use total disputed tax (across all heads).
  • Interest-only, penalty-only, or late fee-only disputes: use corresponding amount.
  • Mixed cases: consider total of interest + penalty + late fee if tax is not disputed.
  • Refund cases: consider total refund amount in dispute.
  • For composite orders covering multiple appeals: use aggregate amount.
  1. Exclusions from Monetary Limit Policy – Appeals Can Be Filed Regardless of Amount:
    Appeals must be filed (irrespective of tax amount) in the following situations:
  • Issues involving constitutional validity of GST provisions, rules, or notifications.
  • Legal interpretation issues (recurring nature) such as valuation, classification, refund, place of supply.
  • Cases where courts have imposed adverse remarks or costs against the government.
  • Any matter deemed fit by CBIC for justice or revenue protection.
  1. No Precedential Value of Non-filing:
  • If an appeal is not filed due to the monetary threshold, it does not imply acceptance of the order by the department.
  • Tax officers must record the reason for not appealing: “disputed issue not accepted, but appeal not filed due to monetary limit.”
  • In future litigation, officers must clarify to GSTAT or court that non-filing was solely due to threshold limits.

Source: Circular No.: 207/01/2024-GST

LEAVE A REPLY