The Pune Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal has partly allowed the appeal of the assessee in Vithalrao Ranganathrao Ambarwadikar v. ACIT, dealing with two distinct issues concerning taxation of capital gains on sale of land and disallowance of interest expenditure.
The assessee, an individual engaged in the business of an HPCL petrol pump dealership, had filed his return for Assessment Year 2013-14 declaring total income of Rs. 15,98,709. During scrutiny proceedings, the Assessing Officer noticed that the assessee had sold land bearing City Survey No. 18348/2/A, admeasuring 1350.25 sq. metres, situated at Hamalwadi near Railway Station, Aurangabad, but had not offered capital gains arising from the transaction to tax. The Assessing Officer consequently made an addition of Rs. 9,92,38,664 as long-term capital gain.
Land Held to Be a Capital Asset
Before the appellate authorities, the assessee contended that the property was agricultural land and therefore did not constitute a capital asset. The Tribunal, however, rejected this contention.
It noted that the land had been purchased from the Maharashtra Housing and Area Development Authority and that no documentary evidence had been produced to establish that it was agricultural land. Significantly, it was also admitted that no agricultural activity had been carried out on the property since 1981. The location of the land, adjacent to Aurangabad Railway Station, was also taken into consideration.
On these facts, the Tribunal held that the property was not agricultural land and constituted a capital asset. Accordingly, the Assessing Officer was justified in taxing the profit arising from its sale as long-term capital gain.
The Tribunal further examined the relevant sale deed and noted that the property was sold on 10 April 2012 and the deed was registered on 11 April 2012. It therefore held that the capital gain was correctly taxable in Assessment Year 2013-14. The assessee’s ground challenging the capital gain addition was consequently dismissed.
Interest Disallowance Deleted Where Own Funds Were Sufficient
The assessee achieved relief on the second issue concerning disallowance of interest expenditure.
The record showed that the assessee had funds amounting to Rs. 17,12,65,921, whereas advances given by him amounted to only Rs. 1,42,56,800. Since the assessee maintained a common fund flow and his own funds were substantially higher than the advances, the Tribunal applied the principle laid down by the Bombay High Court in CIT v. Reliance Utilities & Power Ltd., (2009) 313 ITR 340 (Bom.).
The Tribunal held that where sufficient own funds are available, a presumption can be drawn that the advances were made from such own funds rather than from interest-bearing borrowed funds. It accordingly directed the Assessing Officer to delete the interest disallowance of Rs. 6,50,110.
Key Takeaway
The ruling reiterates two important Income Tax principles. First, merely describing land as agricultural is insufficient; its nature, location, surrounding circumstances, supporting records and actual agricultural use are relevant in determining whether it falls outside the definition of a capital asset. Secondly, where an assessee possesses sufficient interest-free own funds exceeding the amount of advances, the presumption that such advances were made from own funds can protect the corresponding interest deduction.
The appeal was therefore partly allowed, with the long-term capital gain addition sustained while the interest disallowance was deleted.




