Home Case Laws Writ petition challenging GST assessment dismissed as Court held suppression of turnover...

Writ petition challenging GST assessment dismissed as Court held suppression of turnover and excess ITC claim were established, and statutory appeal remedy before Tribunal was available.

0
220

Case: M/s Suraj Agency v. Union of India & Ors.

Court: Patna High Court
Petition No.: Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 3595 of 2025
Date of Judgment: 25 June 2025
Category of Dispute: Assessment under Section 73 – Input Tax Credit & Turnover mismatch
Relevant Sections: Sections 16(2), 50, 73(1), 73(9) CGST/BGST Act, 2017; Rule 142(5) of CGST Rules, 2017

Facts of the case (Paras 2–3)

M/s Suraj Agency faced an ex-parte assessment order dated 06.12.2023 for FY 2018–19, raising demand of ₹44,42,848/– comprising tax, interest, and penalty. The discrepancy arose from turnover mismatch between GSTR-1, GSTR-3B, and GSTR-9, attributed by petitioner to clerical mistakes. The petitioner’s appeal before Additional Commissioner (Appeals) was dismissed on 13.09.2024. Petitioner contended that ITC disallowance on the basis of GSTR-2A was impermissible for FY 2018–19, as Rule 36(4) was introduced only from 09.10.2019.


Questions before the Court

  1. Whether the assessment order and appellate order were invalid for being ex-parte and without due consideration of reconciliation data?

  2. Whether ITC could be denied for FY 2018–19 on the ground of non-reflection in GSTR-2A?

  3. Whether writ jurisdiction could be invoked despite availability of statutory appeal before GST Appellate Tribunal?


Observations of the Court (Paras 8–16)

  • The assessment was framed under Section 73(9) read with Rule 142(5) after scrutiny of annual return for FY 2018–19, finding suppression of turnover and wrongful ITC availment (Paras 8–9).

  • Petitioner was duly served with DRC-01 but failed to respond; hence principles of natural justice were not violated (Para 10).

  • Appellate authority had examined discrepancies in turnover for December 2018 and January 2019, where differences amounted to over ₹4.41 crores. Petitioner failed to substantiate clerical error claims with sale registers or audit reports (Paras 11–13).

  • On ITC, petitioner’s reliance on decisions of Chhattisgarh HC (Bharat Aluminium) and Madras HC (D.Y. Beathel Enterprises) was rejected since petitioner admitted to availing ITC in excess of GSTR-2A without evidence. Section 16(2) eligibility conditions remained mandatory (Paras 12–15).

  • Circular No.183/2022 clarified that differences up to ₹5 lakhs required certificate from supplier, but petitioner produced no such document (Para 15).


Judgment (Paras 17–18)

The High Court held that:

  • Orders were not vitiated by breach of natural justice or jurisdictional error.

  • Petitioner had admitted to excess ITC claim; turnover mismatch was substantiated.

  • As statutory remedy of appeal before the Tribunal existed, writ jurisdiction could not be invoked.

Accordingly, the writ petition was dismissed, with liberty to petitioner to pursue statutory remedies.


Table of Cases Referred

Case Court Ratio / Verdict
M/s Aastha Enterprises v. State of Bihar (CWJC No.10395/2023) Patna HC Upheld validity of Section 16(2); ITC cannot be claimed where supplier has not paid tax.
Bharat Aluminium Co. v. Union of India Chhattisgarh HC Recovery should be from seller if tax not paid, except in exceptional cases.
D.Y. Beathel Enterprises v. State Tax Officer (W.P.(MD) No.2147/2021) Madras HC Recipient cannot be denied ITC solely due to seller’s default; remedy lies against seller.

Between Fine Lines

For businesses, this case underscores that courts will not interfere in writ jurisdiction when statutory remedies exist, especially where discrepancies in turnover and ITC are established. Proper reconciliation of GSTR-1, 3B, 2A, and 9 along with supporting records is crucial, and failure to respond to DRC-01 notices weakens the defense.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY