Home Case Laws Writ Petition could not be entertained in case of delay in filing...

Writ Petition could not be entertained in case of delay in filing of Appeal even after period of limitation provided by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India.

0
570

Case Summary: Badri Prasad Yadav v. State of Bihar

Court: High Court of Patna

Petition No.: Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 3021 of 2023

Category of Dispute: Input Tax Credit

Judgment Date: 18 May 2023

Relevant Sections: Section 16(2), 73, 107(4) of BGST Act, Article 226 of Constitution of India

 

Facts of the Case [¶1, ¶2, ¶6]

The petitioner, Badri Prasad Yadav, challenged the dismissal of an appeal dated 21.09.2022, which had been rejected on the ground of delay. A show-cause notice was issued under Section 73 of the BGST Act on 08.11.2021, and a demand order followed on 27.12.2021. The petitioner filed the appeal only on 02.09.2022, well beyond the limitation period. In his writ, the petitioner admitted to having wrongly claimed Input Tax Credit (ITC) for AY 2020–21 as the supplier had not paid the corresponding tax to the department.

 

Questions in Consideration [¶5, ¶7, ¶8]

  1. Whether the writ petition under Article 226 is maintainable in light of the availability of an appellate remedy under Section 107 of the BGST Act.
  2. Whether the appeal was rightly dismissed as time-barred despite general COVID limitation relief issued by the Supreme Court.
  3. Whether the wrong availment of ITC due to non-payment by the supplier justifies tax demand and denial of ITC under Section 16(2) of the BGST Act.

 

Observations of the Court

  • On Transitional Credit Judgment Cited: The petitioner’s reliance on CWJC No. 2125/2019 concerning transitional credit was misplaced, as the present dispute involved regular ITC under the GST regime, not legacy credits under the VAT Act [¶3–5].
  • On Limitation: The Supreme Court’s suo motu judgment allowed extension of limitation till 28.02.2022 and permitted appeals up to 29.05.2022. The petitioner failed to act within this or even the statutory extended period under Section 107(4), which expired on 28.06.2022. The appeal filed on 02.09.2022 was 65 days late and beyond condonable limits [¶7].
  • On Jurisdiction under Article 226: Citing State of H.P. v. Gujarat Ambuja Cement Ltd., the Court held that writ jurisdiction is discretionary and not available when alternate remedies exist unless there is breach of natural justice, fundamental rights, or jurisdictional error—none of which were pleaded or proven here [¶8–9].
  • On ITC Denial: The Court reiterated that under Section 16(2), ITC is not allowed if the supplier fails to pay tax to the government. The petitioner’s own admission confirmed ineligibility for ITC [¶5].

 

Judgment of the Court [¶12]

The High Court dismissed the writ petition, holding that:

  • There was no justification for invoking extraordinary writ jurisdiction.
  • The appeal was grossly time-barred and not entertainable.
  • No error or breach of natural justice was shown.

 

Between Fine Lines (Summary in 5 Lines):

The petitioner challenged a demand based on denied ITC, but the appeal was filed beyond even the condonable period. He relied on a transitional credit case which was irrelevant. The Court emphasized that ITC is not available if the supplier hasn’t paid tax. No breach of natural justice or jurisdictional error was shown. Hence, the High Court refused to entertain the writ.

Summary of Referred Cases

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
CWJC No. 2125 of 2019 Patna High Court Dealt with transitional credit under VAT regime claimed in GST period. Held inapplicable in this context
Suo Motu WP (C) No. 3 of 2020 (2022) 134 taxmann.com 307/441 ITR 722 (SC) Supreme Court granted general extension for limitation due to COVID-19. Applied, but not helpful to petitioner
State of H.P. v. Gujarat Ambuja Cement Ltd. (2005) 6 SCC 499 Laid down limits of High Court’s writ jurisdiction when alternative statutory remedy is available. Court relied on to reject the writ

Takeaway:

“No ITC Without Supplier’s Tax Payment – Delay and Misplaced Reliance Proved Fatal”

LEAVE A REPLY