Case Summary
Case Title: M/s High Tech Ecogreen Contractors LLP v. Joint Director, DGGI & Ors.
Court: Gauhati High Court
Case No.: WP(C)/4787/2024
Judgment Date: 25.02.2025
Category of Dispute: Input Tax Credit (ITC) – Validity of Rule 36(4) of CGST Rules
Relevant Provisions: Sections 16, 43A, 50, 74(9), 112, 164 of CGST Act; Rule 36(4), Rule 110 of CGST Rules; corresponding provisions of Assam GST Act
Facts (Paras 2–7)
The petitioner, M/s High Tech Ecogreen Contractors LLP, engaged in works contract services, faced a show-cause notice dated 23.12.2021 alleging wrong availment of ITC in contravention of Rule 36(4). The Additional Commissioner (Order-in-Original dated 31.03.2023) confirmed substantial tax, interest, and penalty demands including:
-
Ineligible ITC of ₹1.38 crore,
-
Delayed payment interest of ₹1.11 crore,
-
RCM liability of ₹70 lakh, and
-
Penalties under Section 74(9).
The appeal filed before Commissioner (Appeals) was dismissed as time-barred (Order-in-Appeal dated 12.02.2024). The petitioner then approached the High Court challenging both orders and the constitutional validity of Rule 36(4).
Questions before the Court (Paras 4, 8–10)
-
Whether Rule 36(4) of the CGST Rules is invalid because Section 43A, said to be its enabling provision, was never notified and later omitted.
-
Whether the tax demands for October 2019 to March 2021, based on Rule 36(4), were without authority of law.
-
Whether writ jurisdiction can be invoked despite the availability of an appellate remedy before the Tribunal under Section 112.
Observations (Paras 17–31)
-
Section 43A, though inserted by the CGST (Amendment) Act, 2018, was never notified; hence it never came into operation (Para 23).
-
A rule cannot derive power from a provision that was never enforced; therefore, Rule 36(4) must be examined independently (Para 31).
-
Rule 36 relates to conditions for ITC and is connected with Section 16 (eligibility of ITC), not merely Section 43A (Paras 25–27).
-
Section 164 confers broad rule-making powers; hence Rule 36(4) is validly framed (Paras 26, 28).
-
Petitioner’s reliance on Rule 36(4) in earlier proceedings estops them from questioning its validity simultaneously (Para 29).
-
The Kerala High Court in Nahasshukoor v. AC, SGST upheld Rule 36(4) against constitutional challenge under Article 14, lending persuasive authority (Para 11–12).
Judgment (Paras 30–34)
The Court held:
-
Rule 36(4) is constitutionally and legally valid, deriving authority from Section 16 read with Section 164, not Section 43A.
-
The petitioner’s challenge was only to bypass statutory appeal remedies, which is impermissible.
-
The writ petition was dismissed, but liberty was reserved for the petitioner to pursue appellate remedies under Section 112.
Case Law Table (Referred Cases)
| Case | Court | Citation / No. | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nahasshukoor v. Assistant Commissioner, SGST | Kerala High Court | WP(C) No.1853/2023, 03.11.2023 | Upheld validity of Rule 36(4), held not violative of Article 14. |
Between Fine Lines (Practical Takeaway)
For businesses, this judgment clarifies that Rule 36(4) is a valid restriction on ITC claims, enforceable even before Section 16(2)(aa) was inserted in 2022. The Court’s reliance on Section 16 and Section 164 means taxpayers cannot escape ITC mismatches on the ground that Section 43A was never notified. The ruling underscores the importance of reconciling ITC with supplier invoices and not depending on procedural loopholes.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




